Skip to main content

New England at Denver

I can’t believe what I write sometimes.

Recently on Hole Punch Sports, I said that, “the playoff road looks very favorable for the Broncos.” However, my AFC predictions of Pittsburgh and New England victories last weekend were spot-on. So things went exactly like I said they would, but Denver is facing its toughest possible opponent for this playoff round…which isn’t “very favorable”.

Even though the Broncos stand as three-point favorites, a victory for them would feel like an upset. Why? I’m not really sure, but I think I’d call it “the Patriots won the last two Super Bowls.” As is well-documented, quarterback Tom Brady and head coach Bill Belichick have never lost a playoff game together. Another well-known fact is that this year’s 10-6 mark was dragged down by numerous injuries all over the field. The Patriots are in much better shape heading into Saturday’s game (6 p.m. Mountain, CBS).

Why can the Broncos hope to win?

1. Home-field advantage. Broncos coach Mike Shanahan has not won a playoff game since Jan. 31, 1999-coincidentally, right before Hall of Fame quarterback John Elway retired. But it’s no coincidence that each of the Broncos’ playoff losses since that day have come on the road.

Home-field is big for any franchise, but some teams have an even greater advantage. The weather in Green Bay. The fans in Kansas City. And the altitude in Denver. The Broncos know how to wear teams out in thin air, and proved it this season, winning all eight games at home.

2. Jake Plummer. Plummer certainly doesn’t give the Broncos nearly as much as Brady gives the Patriots. The Broncos’ passing offense is just middle-of-the-pack statistically, whereas Brady has almost single-handedly carried New England’s offense.

But Plummer gets something Brady doesn’t-a crack at the Patriots’ 31st-ranked pass defense. Belichick’s defenses always outperform their regular season numbers in the playoffs, but Plummer ripped the Patriots for huge gains in their regular season meeting (which the Broncos won 28-20).

Plummer’s known best now for his facial hair and newfound caution, but earned a reputation in Arizona for clutch play. He’s nowhere near Brady, of course, but doesn’t have to be, because…

3. The Broncos can run on anybody. Denver ran for more yards this year than any team except the Atlanta Falcons. Both Mike Anderson (1,014 yards) and Tatum Bell (921) ran for more yards than New England’s leading rusher, Corey Dillon. Anderson’s power wears down any defense-especially at altitude-and Bell’s breakaway speed forces opposing DBs to pay more attention to the run.

Meanwhile, New England has no such balance on offense. The Patriots’ run defense does rank eighth in the league, but their undersized defenders will wear down under the relentless onslaught.

4. Mike Shanahan. Or, in other words, New England’s customarily enormous head coaching edge is much smaller than it is over other teams.

In fact, you could argue that New England might not have an edge at all. While Shanahan has fallen somewhat out of favor in recent years, his and Belichick’s career paths are very similar. Both started as head coaches in terrible situations (Shanahan in Oakland, Belichick in Cleveland.) Both rebounded as coordinators for teams that went to the Super Bowl (Shanahan in San Fran., and Belichick in New England). And both won multiple Super Bowls behind quarterbacks who were the best in the game.

Just think about it: if Belichick runs off a few 10-6s and 9-7s in the next few years-certainly possible on a team with some aging defensive playmakers and the built-in disadvantage of always drafting low-will Patriots fans talk about him the same way Broncos fans talk of Shanahan now?

The real coaching question is whether Gary Kubiak’s interviews will distract him from game-planning for the Patriots. Two reasons that won’t happen: first, Kubiak’s not the kind of coaching climber who would jeopardize his current team’s chances; and second, if Shanahan thinks there’s any evidence of a drop-off, he can take over the offense himself. Shanahan knows this is his chance to shut up critics-for now-and the fiery coach won’t let anything stand in his way.

5. Defense. For the last two years, the Broncos had an impressive regular-season defense that completely fell apart against Indianapolis. That won’t happen again (at least until next week).

For starters, the Broncos finally seem to have solved their pass defense woes. And second, they match up very well with the Patriots. The Broncos are slightly vulnerable against the run, but New England can’t and won’t run enough to keep the defense honest. Meanwhile, New England’s offensive gameplan-which will almost certainly be to put the ball in Tom Brady’s hands-plays to Denver’s strength.

Tom Brady can’t really be stopped, but the Broncos can make the Patriots one-dimensional, which is almost always instant death in the playoffs.

The list of reasons for picking New England is much shorter:

1. The history of Tom Brady and Bill Belichick. Yes, the Patriots decided a few years ago to stop losing, and it’s paid off. Brady and Belichick have reached historic greatness in the last few years, and both have already punched their tickets to the Hall of Fame.

But eventually the pair will lose. And while I’m not sure the Patriots’ dynastic run is finished, I do think the next Super Bowl win is on hold for at least another year. Broncos 23, Patriots 21.

Comments

DG said…
So let it be said, so let it be done, Punchinello. Great post. I'm really looking forward to the game in 56 hours and 12 minutes. And to your more frequent posting.
DG
Mike said…
I didn't realize we'd won four of the last five. In that case, I was at the fifth, and so was...starting quarterback Danny Kanell! In other words, that really makes me happy about our chances.

Belichick has done a fantastic job this year...add him to the list of "Coaches Better than Lovie Smith."
David said…
mike.... your comment about belichek possibly being a nascent shanahan was really insightful, and i could totally see it happening.

one of the main reasons i love HPS is that your bias is almost always to my liking. same reason i watch foxnews.

HIYO.

no but really, i like the logic. i think the patriots peaked at the end of the season, but their zenith is about to become season nadir as they come to the mile high city.

we won't lose in mile high. simple. we are healthy, we'll run all over them, plummer will have a solid 20-27 game. couple of td's. i say we we win 31-17
Anonymous said…
I really like the Broncos strong defense, ability to cause and capitolize on turnover, and the few mistakes the Broncos make on offense. I like Denver 27-13.
Mike said…
What's the matter, Dave, didn't feel comfortable thorwing in some exact statistical totals, like "Brady will throw for 341 yards in defeat"? You do see how it puts the time you wrote your comments right under them, right? What do you possibly have to gain from this?

Props to Mr. Clark for nailing the margin of victory, though...

Popular posts from this blog

The NFL hates you.

It's no joke. It seems like the more devoted of a fan you are, the less the league cares about your continued patronage. The best example is the league's blackout policy, a wonderful gift from the league to its teams granting them added market pressure to charge whatever ridiculous amount they want for tickets. If a game doesn't sell out, the home market doesn't get to watch it on TV. (Basically, a 75-mile radius around the stadium doesn't get to see the game on TV if all the tickets aren’t bought first.) The NFL, like a needy girlfriend, says, "Hey, fans, you like us? Prove it." Then the league asks us to prove it again and again, week after week, year after year. I live within 75 miles of what should be John Elway Stadium, but Broncos fans are pretty much shielded from this stuff, right? Not all of them. One of my friends is as supportive a fan as the NFL can have: he's a Broncos season ticket holder and an NFL Sunday Ticket subscriber. That mean...

An innocent mistake

Sorry. Here I am to catch up on a few things from the past week... 1. Vince Young will be on the cover of Madden 08. Good for him, I guess. Much is made of the Madden curse. It's not a self-fulfilling prophecy, but it almost feels like one. The real problem is that a) football is a very violent game, and b) Electronic Arts typically selects a cover athlete who's already very well-known. Unfortunately, the players are therefore often a year (Shaun Alexander) or more (Ray Lewis) off their actual prime, and old enough that a serious injury is more likely. Young is an up-and-comer, and to avoid a horrible pun let's just say he has less age than most of those guys. I think he'll be fine. 2. Of course, the reason EA went with such a youthful player is that superstar Chargers back LaDainian Tomlinson turned them down . Why? Money. No surprise that'd be a point of contention, considering how "generous" EA is with its regular employees . 3. That's why re...

Super Bowl XLVI revealed!

The Patriots and the Giants. Things just work out sometimes. * * * Two new teams, the England Patriots and the York Giants, will play for the NFL title in Super Bowl Forty-Six in two weeks. I can't wait. The matchup comes too late, and after too imperfect of a season, to make up for the wounds inflicted by the Giants in early 2008. The Patriots' undefeated season, a 16-0 masterpiece in which they set the league's single-season scoring record, broke at the hands of the upstart Giants in that year's Super Bowl. The way the Giants won made their win feel especially flukish...Eli Manning, known more for his entitled attitude than his athleticism (the only player to which his moves have ever been compared favorably is his brother Peyton), somehow scrambled free of a Patriot pass rush in the closing minutes, and lofted a pass down the middle of the field to David Tyree, who caught the key throw against the top of his helmet. Then a touchdown pass to Plexiglass provided the wi...