Skip to main content

Super Bowl recap

1. Congratulations to the Colts. To me, the biggest change they made in this year's postseason compared to past years was emphasizing the running game. Why they didn't do that with the Edge, I'll never know.

In their last playoff loss to the Patriots (early 2005), the Colts lost partly because of New England's defense, but the real key was the Pats' ability to control the clock, especially in the second half. In the AFC Championship two weeks ago, the Colts turned the table, and they rode the same formula to success today.

2. The key to any major football championship is surrendering a kickoff return for a touchdown to open the game.

3. What a start for the Bears. First, Devin Hester takes it to the house with a breathtaking return. (Okay, now seriously, of course you'd take the touchdown-but it's too bad it came so early, because Indy was so cautious kicking the rest of the way. Would two long returns that weren't touchdowns have been better?)

Indy got the touchdown to Wayne, but blew the PAT, which could have easily been a bigger deal late. So the Bears still caught a break. Then former C.U. ward power forward Alex Brown broke into Indy's backfield and forced a fumble that led to Muhsin Muhammed's touchdown and a 14-6 lead. Who knew that was the beginning of the end?

(Not me. But it's funny to look back on my notes from the game. The Bears got first-and-goal after Thomas Jones' 52-yard run. They called two runs, gained nothing, and then had to pass, scoring on that throw to Muhammed. I noted at the time that it wasn't much for play-calling. Little did I know what a sign it was of overly-conservative things to come.)

4. Thomas Jones played like Michael Pittman of the Buccaneers did four years ago. Both were busts for the Arizona Cardinals, but both played huge in the Super Bowl. Jones only had fifteen carries, though, which explains how the Colts held him to 112 yards.

5. Rex Grossman was as advertised. (I was wrong; everyone else was right.) I had a good debate with my brother about which of his fourth-quarter interceptions was worse. I favored the first one's unbelievable hangtime towards the sideline, but you can't take anything away from his second pick, a hot-air balloon deep down the middle into double coverage.

6. Quick stop for the ads (watch them online if you don't follow me). First, that Grand Theft Auto/Coca-Cola commercial was tremendous, if only because it reminded me of my old roommate Sam, who once played GTA on my PlayStation and asked how to pick up all the litter strewn on the streets. The second was the Sales Genie ad, which might have been the greatest commercial of all-time. I would hate to meet anyone who was actually impressed by it. Oh, and that GM ad about the yellow assembly-line machine that loses its job and throws itself off a bridge-that was freakin' disturbing.

7. Do I have to mention Peyton Manning? Yes? Then he shouldn't have been MVP-I thought both running backs made more big plays in the second half. I'm not at all surprised he got the MVP with a Colts victory. Of course, who really cares who got that award-either way, he finally got his ring.

8. Adam Vinatieri did miss and even worse, it came after an icing timeout. I hate those-they never work-but they'll obviously be all the rage again next year. Like the bad-snap PAT, though, it didn't end up mattering.

9. Oh, yeah-in the first quarter, Nantz pointed out that on one play, Bears defenders Danieal and Ricky Manning were in the game, and it must have reminded Peyton of playing with Eli and Cooper growing up. Um, I can think of a big reason why it wouldn't have, but more to the point, this is emblematic of one of the reasons I hate Manning. I am so sick of being force-fed him, especially anecdotes about his family. Here's an example-I'm a much bigger fan of Brett Favre or Tom Brady and honestly, I couldn't tell you if either one even has a brother. I'm definitely not going to get teary-eyed remembering Peyton's childhood while I'm watching the Super Bowl, you know?

The craziest part is that Cooper, before an injury ended his playing days, was a wide receiver. His brothers are two of the slowest players in the whole league! I don't get it.

10. For me, one of the weird things about watching a Colts game is seeing offensive coordinator Tom Moore. Okay, Peyton Manning handles a lot of the play-calling and all that. But the Colts have been, over the last several years, an incredibly productive offensive team.

Bear with me for a sec. When Shaq and Kobe were on the same team, you'd hear the announcers drone on about the Lakers even during a Bucks-Clippers game. When the Rams ruled the NFL world, you'd hear about them every time, say, a Dolphins receiver ran for several yards after a catch (as though advancing the football was a revolutionary concept). Now when analysts and experts talk about football, you always hear about Peyton Manning. "He's obviously the top quarterback in the league," they'll say-even though he's not.

My point is, the Colts don't suffer for attention. But you almost never hear about Tom Moore as one of the league's best coaches, even though he's putting up a heck of a track record. Why is that? I guess it's just because he's old, and I suppose I don't really care if he gets more pub-but it's just kind of weird. Usually people on winning teams get too much attention, not too little.

11. Again, I don't like the Colts, but they did win. I've got to say, though, that this Super Bowl reminded me a lot of last year's. For what it's worth, I don't think the Steelers and Colts rank very high among other champions, including recent teams like the Patriots or even the Rams and Ravens.

Comments

John said…
I, of course, agree that this Super Bowl feels a lot like last year's - mediocre action, bad commercials, and underperformance by an NFC team that still surprisingly had a chance to get back in it in the fourth quarter. And the Colts' run has been completely bizarre, not unlike last year's Steelers.

I had the same thought about Hester's return - he pretty much took himself out of the game by breaking a big play early. In the long run, he would have helped his team more by having a number of longer returns - say out to the Bears' 40 - and then breaking one for a touchdown in the 3rd or 4th quarter. That said, though, the returner should never be a team's most productive offensive weapon in a Super Bowl . . .

Urlacher was a huge disappointment, and I don't see how that guy is numbered among the league's elite linebackers.
John said…
And why did the Colts hate Edgerrin James?
David said…
i can't bring myself to care about the superbowls these days... been in a nine year slump.

i liked a few of the commercials, the "slapping faces is the new bumping fists" was pretty amusing.

Popular posts from this blog

The NFL hates you.

It's no joke. It seems like the more devoted of a fan you are, the less the league cares about your continued patronage. The best example is the league's blackout policy, a wonderful gift from the league to its teams granting them added market pressure to charge whatever ridiculous amount they want for tickets. If a game doesn't sell out, the home market doesn't get to watch it on TV. (Basically, a 75-mile radius around the stadium doesn't get to see the game on TV if all the tickets aren’t bought first.) The NFL, like a needy girlfriend, says, "Hey, fans, you like us? Prove it." Then the league asks us to prove it again and again, week after week, year after year. I live within 75 miles of what should be John Elway Stadium, but Broncos fans are pretty much shielded from this stuff, right? Not all of them. One of my friends is as supportive a fan as the NFL can have: he's a Broncos season ticket holder and an NFL Sunday Ticket subscriber. That mean...

An innocent mistake

Sorry. Here I am to catch up on a few things from the past week... 1. Vince Young will be on the cover of Madden 08. Good for him, I guess. Much is made of the Madden curse. It's not a self-fulfilling prophecy, but it almost feels like one. The real problem is that a) football is a very violent game, and b) Electronic Arts typically selects a cover athlete who's already very well-known. Unfortunately, the players are therefore often a year (Shaun Alexander) or more (Ray Lewis) off their actual prime, and old enough that a serious injury is more likely. Young is an up-and-comer, and to avoid a horrible pun let's just say he has less age than most of those guys. I think he'll be fine. 2. Of course, the reason EA went with such a youthful player is that superstar Chargers back LaDainian Tomlinson turned them down . Why? Money. No surprise that'd be a point of contention, considering how "generous" EA is with its regular employees . 3. That's why re...

Super Bowl XLVI revealed!

The Patriots and the Giants. Things just work out sometimes. * * * Two new teams, the England Patriots and the York Giants, will play for the NFL title in Super Bowl Forty-Six in two weeks. I can't wait. The matchup comes too late, and after too imperfect of a season, to make up for the wounds inflicted by the Giants in early 2008. The Patriots' undefeated season, a 16-0 masterpiece in which they set the league's single-season scoring record, broke at the hands of the upstart Giants in that year's Super Bowl. The way the Giants won made their win feel especially flukish...Eli Manning, known more for his entitled attitude than his athleticism (the only player to which his moves have ever been compared favorably is his brother Peyton), somehow scrambled free of a Patriot pass rush in the closing minutes, and lofted a pass down the middle of the field to David Tyree, who caught the key throw against the top of his helmet. Then a touchdown pass to Plexiglass provided the wi...