Skip to main content

Cutler v. Marshall

There's an article up about an interview Denver Broncos quarterback Jay Cutler did today with the Associated Press. In it, he covers a few topics, the headliner being his disappointment in wide receiver Brandon Marshall.

Marshall suffered a serious injury last month when his arm went through an entertainment center. Yes, really. The article says that the injury came when Marshall was "horsing around", which is awful if the pun was intended. But the injury was serious; Broncos' trainer Steve Antonopulos said in a statement that Marshall cut an artery, a vein, a nerve, two tendons, and three muscles. Ye-ouch.

The extent of the injuries makes the whole episode sound a lot worse than garden-variety wrestling. Still, though. You can call Brandon Marshall a chump, and you can laugh at his misfortune if you want, but I don't think you can call this an indictment of his character. Cutler disagrees:

'I've talked to him many times. I think a lot of people have. ... He knows he's running out of chances,' Cutler said. 'This wasn't like his DUI and other stuff he's had. It was an accident, but still, things like that can't happen. He knows it.

'But like I told him, I said, 'Brandon, they're going to quit giving you chances and you're going to have to go somewhere else. And that's going to be a shame.''

What does that even mean: it was an accident, but it still can't happen? I don't know. Also, as long as Marshall keeps producing like he did last season (102 catches for 1,325 yards and 7 TDs last year), he's not going anywhere, as the DUI proved. (Maybe I'm crazy, but a DUI bothers me a lot more than "horseplay", and I don't remember Cutler saying anything last year.) Anyway, I thought the article seemed to sensationalize a little bit, but Cutler wasn't exactly holding back:

'His DUI was a wakeup call,' Cutler retorted. 'He's had many wakeup calls. I mean, he's been in [coach Mike] Shanahan's office many times. I've been up there with him. He said the same thing: 'This is a wakeup call. This is the last thing that's going to happen. Blah blah blah.' I mean, until he goes out and proves it, we'll see what happens. [And you know, deep down I feel bad for those players who are expected to prove things.]'

Wait, why the heck would Cutler be up there with him? The quarterback comes to your performance reviews now? Anyway, what amuses me about the interview is that it seems like the whole thing sprang from somebody telling Cutler to act like a leader. Odd thing is, running to the press won't help that cause the way playing like a first-rounder would.

Cutler said of Javon Walker, who left for Oakland:

'You've got to have a No. 1 guy you want to go to. I think Brandon was going to be my guy. I don't know if Javon was going to be OK with 40, 50, 60 balls [considering I'd throw at least 20 of those over his head and into the stands.]'

I don't know, check it out, tell me if I'm being too harsh.

Comments

blaine said…
Ha ha, I loved the 20 balls over his head comment. I think Cutler has a right to be frustrated with Marshall, especially when you consider the DUI from last year. However, I agree with you, that should be kept between him and Marshall. There's no need to be saying that stuff to the media. If Elway had said what Cutler said, we wouldn't even be talking about this, but the fact is, Cutler isn't exactly impressing a lot of people with his performance on the field. If Cutler wants to show people he's a leader, he should start by getting the ball in the endzone when the team is in the redzone.
John said…
This whole interview smacks of Cutler trying to step up as a leader but lacking the leadership skills to get it done. There was no reason to air this kind of frustration publicly, and doing so only makes Cutler look like an immature chump.

I bet Shammy-hands was the one who put Cutler up to assuming a leadership role, given that (1) Cutler is obviously Shammy's favorite if he gets to sit in on the performace evaluations and (2) no one listens to Shammy directly anymore. But if this is the best he can offer, we are in some serious trouble.

I agree that it is lame to come down on Marshall for what is obviously an accident - but, on the other hand, a guy with a big-time NFL contract should take better care of himself. The real frustration is that Marshall is now our entire receiving corps, so if he is out, Cutler is really going to light up the over-the-head throwing numbers.
Mike said…
Cap, your theory about Shanahan had me laughing. And I totally agree it felt like someone trying to be a leader rather than someone just being a leader.

Plus it's lame that someone would even try to look like a leader to the public. Who friggin' cares? I wonder if most football teams even have "leaders" the way we talk about them. I bet if they do, it's a non-quarterback more often than not. I mean, a few years ago there was all this talk about how Al Wilson was taking the entire defense out to dinner every week, and he was obviously one of the baddest guys on any field he'd ever stepped on...if you were on that team, wouldn't you care more about the tone he set than whatever Jake Plummer said? Obviously if you have Tom Brady or Brett Favre on your team that's another story, but that's rare.

Popular posts from this blog

Five mini-columns

In this in-between time at the start of football and late-but-not-that-late in the everlasting baseball season, there's not any one topic that stands out, so I thought I'd give you my well thought out opinions on five things in sports (originally ten, but I let No. 3 run so long that I thought I'd cut it short (having now finished this, I realize the word short is out of place here)). This probably means I'll have nothing to write about for weeks, so enjoy. Keep in mind that a) I came up with this list at 2 a.m. this morning (I couldn't sleep and I'm not kidding; you have no idea the kind of pressure that comes with running this website) and b) I'm still not making any money off this, so if it makes no sense, blame yourself (which, interestingly enough, also makes no sense). And we're off! 1) Maurice Clarett vs. Ohio State: Before you skip down to No. 2, which I would certainly do in your position, hear me out. There is actually a little timeliness to t...

And now that it’s gone, it’s like it wasn’t there at all

I never thought this blog would last longer than Jay Cutler's career with the Denver Broncos. He was a talented young prospect so good that the Broncos, a powerhouse organization only one game removed from the Super Bowl the season before, traded up to get him—or, in other words, a player whose upside was so huge, the team sacrificed its present to get his future. And now? He's gone . How did it come to this? * * * Often I'll play devil's advocate with a move like this; you know, I'll try and explain how it makes sense from the other side of the table. Today, during the most disastrous Broncos offseason in memory—and the draft hasn't even happened yet, so settle in—I just don't have it in me. I don't think move is really defensible from a football standpoint. But what the heck: as the article above says, the Broncos are sending Cutler and a fifth-round draft pick this month to the Chicago Bears for quarterback Kyle Orton, Chicago's first-rounder in t...

Did CU ever win the Pac-12?

In 2010, I bet a college buddy of mine (who longtime readers may remember as the only other contributor to Hole Punch Sports) that CU’s football team would not win the Pac-12 in the next 15 years. Guess what? It’s time for me to gloat, because I was right. Why we were doomed Back in the day, a lot of people made the argument that CU should join the Pac-12 because we’d get so much more TV money there. Of course, given college football is the answer to the question, “what if you had a sport where multiple teams were like the Yankees, and you created a whole universe of haves and have-nots?”, then yeah, you want to be aligned with some of the haves. But the question in my mind wasn’t, “will CU be better off with more money?” That’s an obvious yes. The question I asked was, will CU be any more competitive in their own conference if they’re competing against teams who are also getting more money? I couldn’t see why they would be. The mathematical angle Legend has it that Cowboys runn...